Imagine this: the Atlanta Braves, a team known for their strategic moves, are facing a critical decision that could shape their future. But here's the twist: their current shortstop situation is more precarious than most fans realize. After letting Dansby Swanson walk in 2022, the Braves have struggled to find a consistent presence at shortstop. Since 2023, they’ve shuffled through eleven players, with only Orlando Arcia’s magical first half in 2023 coming close to league-average performance. And this is the part most people miss: the current starters, Ha-Seong Kim and Mauricio Dubón, are both free agents after the 2026 season. So, what’s the plan for 2027?
For 2026, the Braves seem set with Kim on a $20 million salary and Dubón as his backup. However, Kim’s return came after he failed to secure a long-term deal in free agency, settling for a 'pillow deal' with Atlanta. His performance in 2026 will be crucial—if he returns to his 2023 form, he’ll be one of the most sought-after free agents next winter. But here’s where it gets controversial: can the Braves retain him, especially with their 'Atlanta Max' salary cap of $22 million? Or will they risk losing him to another team, potentially gaining only a draft pick as compensation?
An early extension seems logical, but Scott Boras, Kim’s agent, rarely negotiates before free agency. However, the looming threat of a lockout and the presence of Kim’s friend Jurickson Profar in Atlanta could sway him. Alternatively, the Braves could pivot to Dubón, who is a defensive stalwart but has seen his offensive numbers decline over the past three seasons. Here’s the question: Can Dubón’s versatility and defensive prowess outweigh his offensive shortcomings, or will the Braves need to look elsewhere?
The free agent market for shortstops in 2027 is thin, with Kim as the standout option. This scarcity might force the Braves to explore trades. Potential targets include young players like Jeremy Peña, CJ Abrams, and Zach Neto, or veterans like Corey Seager and Trevor Story. But here’s a wild idea: Matt McLain of the Cincinnati Reds, a former shortstop with speed and defensive skills, could be a trade target if his bat rebounds. However, his injury history and the Reds’ frugality make this a risky but intriguing option.
Internal options like John Gil, Alex Lodise, and Cody Miller are unlikely to be ready by 2027, leaving the Braves in a bind. The bottom line: Atlanta’s front office, led by Alex Anthopoulos, must balance competing in 2026 with securing a long-term solution at shortstop. Without a clear plan, their championship aspirations could be in jeopardy. What do you think? Should the Braves extend Kim, rely on Dubón, or pursue a trade? Let’s debate in the comments!
